Apology V. Crito - 1036 Words

When reading the Apology one gets a feel for disobeying the law when the law stands in between of what one believes and what the law states. In the Crito one gets the feel of ethical conduct, to obey the laws, and to endure the blows one has received and accept them regardless of the consequences. The only problem with this is that the sequel contradicts the prequel. In the Apology, Socrates threatens to disobey a court order to cease philosophizing, among other orders. In the Crito, Socrates obeys the orders of the state and doesn’t break out of prison even though he is facing an execution. One might say â€Å"did Socrates lose his edge, did he give up because he was condemned to death?† I say that he was caught in his own hypocritical†¦show more content†¦One could refute that while Socrates was given these unjust orders, these orders came from an unjust short lived government, which had a habit of bestowing unjust actions such as these, one could also ask ‘why should Socrates even comply with this new and unjust government? What have they done to benefit Socrates? What patronage has this government given to Socrates? Socrates doesn’t owe them anything so why should he give them anything?’ Well the answer is simple; Socrates didn’t know that this new government was only going to be there for six months, for all he knew this was his new, permanent government, unjust or not he shouldn’t have defied it. He made have not had enough time to make an ‘agreement’ with the new government, but he certainly had an agreement with the country and its people, and yet he still broke it. This clearly shows how Socrates ignored the laws in the Apology. In the Crito, Socrates refuses to escape because he would be defying the laws which he has made and agreement with. Socrates had a chance to brake free, but instead chose to have an imaginary discussion with the Athenian laws. Did Socrates have an epiphany while sleeping in his jail cell? Did he see the error of his ways? Was he a flip flopper? Or perhaps a devil’s advocate? Or even a hypocrite? No, Socrates was simply being Socrates.Show MoreRelatedBroken Family3761 Words   |  16 PagesBody and soul are separate, then 2 .CRITO BY: PLATO The dialogue begins with Socrates waking up to the presence of Crito in his prison cell and inquires whether it is early in the day. Crito informs Socrates that it is indeed early and that he, Crito, chose to let Socrates sleep in peace, especially given Socrates current distressful circumstance of awaiting his own execution. Crito explains that he admires the peaceful manner in which Socrates has heretoforeRead MoreEssay on Sophism: Plato and Pericles2666 Words   |  11 Pageschanges in decision-making and in last part I will talk about Socrates use of cross-examination to find out the meaning of the oracle’s message. As a source of information I am going to use Plutarch’s essays Pericles and Alcibiades, Plato’s Apology and Crito, and Thucydides’ Peloponnesian War. I The meaning of sophism. In Athens all young aristocrats were getting traditional education in gymnasium. They studied music, poetry, mathematics, athletics, etc. But for some wealthy aristocrats it wasRead MoreThe Question of Socrates Obedience3243 Words   |  13 Pagestake poison, or should he have acted to preserve his own life by choosing exile or escaping? In The Trial and Death of Socrates, the question is posed to the philosopher whether it is right to act in ones own best interest or to obey the State. Crito argues that the States punishment of Socrates is unjust, but Socrates argues rather that authority comes from God and that to flee the States decision would be like fleeing God, which would neither be good nor in ones best interest. According toRead MorePlatos Works Essay examples1881 Words   |  8 PagesGlaucon. Socrates shows that it is more natural for a man to be just rather than unjust if his soul is healthy and each part is doing its proper work. Book V takes a position between pure theory and pinpoint detail. Here, Socrates admits he does not like to deal with detail, but is forced to. The Republic throughout shows the ideal. In Book V, Socrates discusses the fact that the ideal is not intended as a blue-print, but rather for comparison. He says women could possibly be equal to men, but wereRead More Atheism as a historical philosophy and its relevance in contemporary America4178 Words   |  17 Pageshardihood to avow that he does not believe in God, shows a recklessness of moral character and utter want of moral sensibility, such as very little entitles him to be heard or believed in a court of justice in a country designated as Christian† (Odell v. Koppee). Of course, this is not the case – even Plato recognized that fact. In his dialogue Euthypryo, Plato’s protagonist Socrates asks, do the gods choose what is good because it is good, or is the good good because the gods choose it? If the formerRead M orePolitical Philosophy and Plato Essay9254 Words   |  38 Pageshis certainty of being able to make a fortune, if he chose to practice the art of pandering. For his part as a philosophical interlocutor, he leads his respondent to a clearer conception of wisdom, although he claims he is not himself a teacher (Apology). His role, he claims, is more properly to be understood as analogous to a midwife (ÃŽ ¼ÃŽ ±Ã¡ ¿â€"ÃŽ ± maia). Socrates explains that he is himself barren of theories, but knows how to bring the theories of others to birth and determine whether they are worthy orRead More George Gemistos Plethon on God: Aristotle vs Plato Essay4387 Words   |  18 PagesMediaeval Period, only the Timaeus in the partial translation of Calcidius was available. The Meno and Phaedo were translated in the twelfth century by Henricus Aristippus, but remained little studied.(4) Leonardo Brunis translations of the Phaedo, Apology, Crito, and Phaedrus were made only shortly before Gemistoss v isit. Among the attendees of these lectures was Cosimo dMedici. Cosimo later founded the Accademia Platonica in Florence. The first director of the Academy was Marsilio Ficino. Ficino recorded